| Although Little Thieves is a romantic fantasy for young adults, the depth of theme and characterization are more typical of fantasy novels written for adult readers. The main character, Vanja, is a sixteen-year-old thief and former maid who has survived abuse and neglect from her parents and employers. She’s created her own way in the world by being clever and resourceful, yet remains hindered by fear and resentment. Vanja’s journey of healing forms the heart of the novel. It's also a story of power and powerlessness, of privilege and disadvantage, of resentment and forgiveness. And it's a deft, nuanced exploration of the power dynamics of abuse, and the ways humans both seek and resist self-empowerment and healing |
| Each section within the book begins with a “Once upon a time . . .” fairy-tale that sets the stage for the following narrative. In the first, Vanja’s biological mother abandons her to the gods Death and Fortune, who become Vanja’s godmothers. We also see snippets of Vanja’s life as a chambermaid, and get a compelling riddle-tale foreshadowing the novel’s climax (“Once upon a time, three maidens went to a wolf’s wedding”), which heightens the tension over Vanja’s fate while giving nothing away. This tale ends with the line: “Which of the maidens was I?” harkening to the classic riddle-rhyme, “As I was Going to St. Ives,” but more meaningful and with much higher stakes than the nursery rhyme. |
| In the novel’s opening, Vanja is stealing jewelry from the nobility hoping to amass enough wealth to flee to another country. Her two God-mothers, Death and Fortune, decreed that on her thirteenth birthday she must choose to serve one of them for all time. Unable to choose between them—because she loves them both—and hurt that they want her to be a servant rather than a daughter, she refuses and decides to leave the country where they're worshipped. Vanja’s clever thievery was one of my favorite parts of the book. These passages reminded me of my favorite heist stories, with Vanja several steps ahead of everyone else . . . until she isn’t. But even when seemly trapped with no escape, she never stops scheming and trying to overcome all obstacles. |
| On her way home from the opening heist, Vanja runs afoul of a local Herne-like forest deity who curses her for stealing one of the god’s talismans. Vanja begins sprouting rubies and diamonds (a twist on the fairy tale Diamonds and Toads), triggering sometimes farcical—but always dangerous—greed in others. The forest god’s half-mortal daughter Ragne comes along to supervise the curse until the full moon, when Vanje will either extricate herself by amending her greedy ways, or become a pile of jewels. I enjoyed Ragne’s curiosity about the mortal world of her unknown father and her naive questions. It was especially fun when she falls in love with another character and asks about kissing. |
| Another adversary is Emric Conrad, a junior prefect sent to investigate the robberies. He appears easily flustered and overwhelmed, stammering through early interviews of Vanja. Very different from the menacing Conrad of the original Goose Girl fable. We discover that Emric, like Vanja, is more complex than his initial presentation conveys. He carries emotional scars from trying to live up to his father’s legacy and expectations, and from painful social awkwardness around his less brilliant peers. Emric serves as a foil, a threat, and a potential romantic partner for Vanja, though the enemies-to-lovers trope never feels forced or simplistic. |
| There are a number of supernatural creatures in the novel such as a kolbold who keeps the hearthfires and nachtmahren who feed off nightmares. I wasn't entirely sure what the magical “rules” were of these creatures, the nachtmahren in particular. They seemed able to change size, and both feed off people and enter inside them at one point. |
Other weaknesses were secondary characters and plotlines not critical to the storyline, including an over-the-top scene with an animated statue. This sprawl gave the novel a frantic feel at times, but overall the story was well-constructed and kept my interest.
In the end, characters are redeemed, evil is vanquished, and love blossoms. Little Thieves is a fairy-tale retelling that is both original and surprisingly complex.
For other “romantasy” novels, try Swordheart, Paladin’s Grace, The Unspoken Name,
The Thousand Eyes, Fire Logic, Earth Logic