| Ithaca tells the story of Penelope from Greek myth who must fight off suitors and protect her country from civil war in the ten-year absence of her husband, Odysseus. Penelope navigates a political tightwire by feigning indifference to the various suitors in order to maintain a tense and precarious balance of power among them. A kindly Egyptian threatens to upset the balance when he starts tutoring her son, Telemachus, in the arts of war. Penelope clearly explains that if she should show him favor, the other suitors would kill him. Near the end, she advises the Egyptian to leave Ithaca if he would live—but he's been sent by his powerful older brother and can’t leave without disinheriting himself. |
Rosy-fingered dawn crawled its way across Ithaca’s back like an awkward lover fumbling at long skirts.
From this termite hall [the palace] the kings of Ithaca send forth their commands across the western isles, all of which are far more pleasant than this wretched rock.
We soon learn the narrator is the goddess Hera, who has taken a particular interest in Queen Penelope.
She invites the reader deeper into the story:
Follow me through the halls of the palace of Odysseus, follow to hear the stories that the men-poets of the greedy kings do not tell.
Here she describes Odysseus’s father, Laertes:
[He was] an Argonaut, no less, a man who once sailed, under my banner, to fetch the golden fleece, before that little shit Jason betrayed me.
| Throughout the story, Penelope is smart and resourceful. When the island is attacked by pirates, the men are too busy competing among themselves to coordinate a proper militia. She organizes the women in the island’s defense. This was one of my favorite aspects of the story: her recruitment of an Amazon to train the women, the participation of the goddess Artemis, and the women smartly playing to their strengths. The way they lay a cunning trap for the pirates—and reveal the suitor behind the attacks—is masterful. I also loved how the men dismissed Penelope’s confession of how she actually pays for the nightly feasts for her suitors (through her own ingenuity and skillful trading). They believe Odysseus left her a horde of gold that she keeps hidden and nothing will dissuade them of this myth. |
In her husband’s absence during the war, Clytemnestra ruled like a true queen—and is loath to surrender that power when her swaggering bully of a husband returns from Troy.
| Her son, Orestes, is duty-bound to avenge his father’s death, even if killing his own mother will condemn him to the wrath of the Furies. The most arresting character in this subplot is Clytemnestra’s daughter Elektra. She witnessed her older sister’s sacrifice at the start of the Trojan war, and has a strained relationship with her mother. Elektra is the only one who sees through the false trail Penelope lays trying to protect her cousin and forces a reckoning with her mother. Throughout her flight, Clytemnestra remains a proud queen—who is nevertheless ruled by love for her son, Orestes. |
“Darling boy,” she says, holding out her arms to him. He does not move to meet her embrace, shows no reaction, his brows buried like a mine. She lowers her arms, steps toward him anyway. “You look . . . well.”
This psychic unraveling of an otherwise powerful woman parallels Penelope’s journey with her son.
| Penelope’s son, Telemachus, is desperate to become a man. His struggles with his masculinity (and his rejection of Penelope’s mothering) form a critical emotional subplot. The more Telemachus draws away from her, the more Penelope clings. Cunning, resourceful, and composed in every other situation, she falls apart around her son. There’s a painful scene where she pounds on his door and he sits on the crate he’s used to bar entry, feeling the vibrations of her pounding fists and saying nothing. Penelope’s angst over her son sets up the finale of the story, which was the one element that didn’t work for me. I re-read the ending several times and I researched the actual myth upon which this novel is based, but was left with the conclusion that the author was simply attempting to create a cliffhanger to compel readers to continue onto the sequel. An unfortunate choice as the ending ruined the reading experience for me and honestly made no sense. |
Babylonia, The Witch’s Heart, Spear, Song of the Huntress, Sistersong, The Queens of Innis Lear
Read more about Greek myth: Medusa, Sirens Empowered,
#MeTooMedusa, Justice, The Spring Maiden