| The Bewitching is told from three points of view: Minerva, a scholarship student at an elite New England college in 1998; Her grandmother, Alba, as a teenager in 1908 living on the family’s ranch; and a few chapters from the 1934 diary of a horror writer named Beatrice. Telling the story through three separate characters in three separate timelines works for the most part, though I found myself feeling distant from the story at times and not equally invested in all three plotlines. There was enough mystery and suspense to draw me along to see how the story turned out. The villains were foreshadowed, and the resourcefulness of the surviving women given just enough setup to make the climax plausible without overplaying it. |
| Having a skeptical character is often used to encourage the reader’s suspension of disbelief, but Minerva didn’t draw me in. I found her prickly and a poor decision-maker. Her self-denial bordered on becoming implausible at times. Seriously, when you’ve had more than one run-in with a hostile man on campus, don’t walk through the woods alone at night. Accept the ride home from your friend. |
| Alba (1908) is the most vivid character and most relatable. She’s a teenager infatuated with her handsome uncle Arturo, who’s cultured and well-dressed. She dreams of living in the city like him. Though she strives to mimic his sophistication, she’s also drawn to the simple magics and superstitions of the locals, and one boy in particular, Valentin. Rumors of a curse haunting her family after her father’s death lead her to follow Valentin into the hills to consult witches. She is quoted throughout the book saying “When I was a young woman, there were still witches.” |
Opening. “Some moments return to us, intact and incandescent, undimmed by the passage of time. It is like that when I remember that December of 1934 and the night Virginia Somerset went missing.”
Closing. “That was when I spotted the terrible darkness in Virginia’s eyes. The seeds of tragedy had taken root by then.”
Opening. “The boy showed up at our dorm two weeks before Halloween.”
Closing. “I think we are all terrified children attempting to shield ourselves from the true horror, and that we recognized the indications of a great evil, a terrible darkness, stretching out like a gnarled, clawed hand that scratched the back of our necks.”
| The author did a wonderful job deftly sketching the world and secondary characters. Here a friend of Beatrice describes both her and the milieu of 1934 at an elite college: “Betty was a poor girl trying to move up in the world and I was a Jewish boy from Brighton. And there was the fact that she liked women, and I didn’t find anyone attractive, so that put us in a different spot than the others.” |
Minerva: Rather than phoning [her friend] Hideo, she stopped by the liquor store and purchased a bottle of wine and a six-pack of beer. She stuffed them in her backpack and walked to campus. . . . “I come bearing gifts,” she said, and pulled out the beer.
| Alba: The bites on her wrist and breast stung, but he’d hardly drunk from her, a sip or two and nothing more. Yet the strength of him was frightening. . . . He’d been kind to her before, he’d played the sweet lover, moving gently. But that was not his nature. He was a glutton. She’d thought to make her flesh into a snare, but he was terribly strong, and as he burrowed his head into her shoulder, muttering a word that was more a growl, she wondered whether he’d trapped her instead. . . . I’ve hunted you, she thought. But then again, the hunt is not over until the quarry lies unmoving and cold. |
She finished unzipping the backpack’s pocket. [NAME’s] back was to her, but [NAME] looked over [a] shoulder at Minerva and Minerva stilled her hands. . . .
| I’m going to die, she thought. I’m going to die, but I’m not going down easily. . . . Minerva felt . . . like she waved a piece of meat in front of a great white shark. . . . “I’m going to thoroughly enjoy drinking your blood and eating your heart.” “I hope you choke on it.” . . . It ought to work. Then again, it was simply a story she’d heard late at night. It might have been made up. It might not work on someone like [NAME]. ... |
| Alba: His eyes vivisected her where she stood, even as his voice was a velvety whisper, and she knew he did not lie. His sincerity made her want to weep. . . . Under his skin she felt the throbbing pull of magic, the power embedded in his bones, and, deeper yet, the awful extent of his appetite. He’d eat her whole. . . . “My love,” he said. His voice was appallingly soft, tinged with an unbearable affection that was ghastlier than his cruelty. |